The question was: What stuffed toy scared Cael to tears when he was little?
The lovely Manuela informed me that the Hint to the question was misquoted, and she's absolutely right! Although the question was correct, and the My Pet Monster answers everyone gave were also correct, the Hint should have read: It was given by Tony to Dex on his sixth birthday. These boys and their toys. Thank you Manuela for finding that!
And the winner is:
Khadijah, I'll be in contact regarding your win!
Thank you again all so much for joining in the fun, and for all your awesome support of these fellas!